A Sukkot Reflection: The Fragility of Our Lives

Health, Jewish Family Service, The Jewish Outlook

Sep 23, 2021

As I write this, our Jewish community is celebrating Sukkot. We spend the holiday in a sukkah, a structure that symbolizes the protection and shelter G-d provided as we passed through the Sinai desert.

Of course, the sukkah is a temporary structure with only a partial roof. So, while we’re inside, we’re somewhat protected – but not much. If it rains, we’ll get wet. If it’s hot out, we’ll be hot.

Why would we use such an insecure structure as a symbol of G-d’s protection? The idea is that we’re not supposed to feel very secure. The sukkah reminds us that in the end, we’re still essentially vulnerable to life’s ups and downs.

And sometimes we can forget this. We get comfortable in our routine, in our comforts, in our home, in the support of our family and friends. We relax in the predictability of our day-to-day… right up until something happens to disrupt our lives and strip away that false sense of security.

In fact, people all need that sense of security. We see this across the lifespan. For example, many children of divorce don’t understand what has happened. The uncertainty is scary, as they feel as if the situation is beyond their control. Children often create a narrative that isn’t so scary. They blame themselves for the divorce and believe that if they behave just right, their parents will get back together.

We see the same need for security in the classic stages of grief. The third stage is bargaining: “G-d, if you just let her live, I promise I’ll be a better person.” Or we fixate on what-ifs: “If only I’d said just the right thing, at just the right moment, they’d still be here.” These reflect our need for a sense of control, eliminating what feels uncertain or unpredictable.

When something happens that destroys our sense of security – confronting us with our true vulnerability – that’s a rude awakening. It hurts.

Our time in the sukkah reminds us that we are not that secure after all. We’re vulnerable. We’re fragile. Ideally, by taking this reminder to heart, we prepare ourselves against future hurts.

At the same time, there will always be some tragedies beyond our capacity to absorb. We may be subjected to violence. We may lose someone close or in a difficult way. We may suffer other events we aren’t prepared for. After such a trauma, it can be hard to recover our emotional balance again.

Some of Jewish Family Service’s work is to help people with this healing process. If life throws you too far off balance, we’re here to help.

Written by Matt Smith, LMS (JFS Therapist)

Latest Posts

Austin Launches First Reset & Refresh Cohort  

Austin Launches First Reset & Refresh Cohort  

Reset & Refresh participants at the Austin Salt Cave. Courtesy: Alachua Haskins By Alachua Haskins    This summer, Austin had the opportunity to become one of the first four pilot communities to launch Reset & Refresh, alongside Portland, Oregon, Atlanta,...

Community Members Make an Impact With Tax-Smart Giving Strategies  

Community Members Make an Impact With Tax-Smart Giving Strategies  

Shalom Austin Legacy Donor Marianne Rochelle. Courtesy: Marianne Rochelle  Shalom Austin Board Chair Seth Halpern. Courtesy: Seth Halpern  As the end of the calendar year approaches, this is a time many people focus on charitable giving. While most people reach for...

Shalom Austin Observes Suicide Prevention Month  

Shalom Austin Observes Suicide Prevention Month  

Actors performing in the play "Right Before I Go" at the Georgetown Palace Theater. Credit: Jon Kniss By Amanda Mills    (CONTENT ADVISORY - Mentions of suicide.)  September is National Suicide Prevention Month – a time to acknowledge all who have died by suicide or...